. BSGAC Banner Logo
Click for Calendar

BSGAC Member Rental Units

Enjoy true resort style living.

Make the most of your stay in the Burnt Store area by renting a property that holds an Activity Membership

in the Burnt Store Golf & Activity Club.

BSGAC allows owners of Rental Units to share full Activity Membership privileges with their renters if they choose to offer this valuable service.

Below is a list of Rental Properties that offer Activity Member Privileges at BSGAC.  The form for a BSGAC Member to have their property included in this list is available online and in the Administration office.

Whether you play golf or just enjoy the socials, activities, card groups, classes, library and free WiFi at the Clubhouse, you can look forward to a good time with friendly members and staff.

For those interested in fishing, Burnt Store Anglers are also part of the Club and our Affinity program offers special rates for Fishing charters to our members.

You will also enjoy a 15% discount in the Linkside Café serving breakfast and lunch plus a 15% discount in the Pro Shop for merchandise, club rental, golf rounds, cart rental, and driving range. Special member discounts are also available in the Affinity Program.

See our Membership Page for a complete list of Benefits for Activity Members.

Temporary membership cards will be issued for renters for the period of their stay. These cards must be presented for all transactions at the Club.  If the card has not been left by the owner, please come into the Activity Office to pick it up.

RENTAL PROPERTIES WITH BSGAC MEMBERSHIP PRIVILEGES
(Blue text in table below indicates a hyperlink)

Property Address Owner Contact
3460 Sunset Key Circle
A  - Emerald Isle
Marvin & Toby Plesser diane.ruley@floridamoves.com
941-347-6337
941-637-8022 FAX
3181 Matecumbe Key Rd
Unit 29 - The Resort
David & Barbara Houser cpmc-bsm@comcast.net
877-276-3300
941-639-4887 FAX
3170 Matecumbe Key Rd
Unit 137 - Keel Club
Todd & Diane Mattas trmattas@comcast.net
941-505-2945
941-637-1667 FAX
5 Pirates Lane
54 B - Commodore Club
Todd & Diane Mattas trmattas@comcast.net
941-505-2945
941-637-1667
2060 Matecumbe Key Rd
2706 - Harbor Tower 2
Bob Wood bjwood5113@yahoo.com
941-575-2290
3329 Sunset Key Circle
704 - Grande Isles III
Gary Tenharmsel g_tenharmsel@comcast.net
616-836-1496
5050 Marianne Key
6C - Halyard Club
Cal & Valerie Hersom chersom@atd-us.com
704-992-2787
2090 Matecumbe Key
1103 - Harbor Towers 1
Haering Family Partnership terific@quikenet.com 
941-639-7753
1001 Islamorada Blvd
12A - Rudder Club
Melodye Demastus mdemastus@columbus.rr.com
614-579-9192
614-771-8814 FAX
3191 Matecumbe Key Rd
401 - Vista Del Sol
Jan Green
Green Acres II LLC
dgjg@roadrunner.com
740-703-2078
740-703-2078 FAX
3313 Sunset Key Circle
205 - Grande Isle I
Cynthia & Carl Ramsey cynthia@signsamerica.com
415-710-7446
415-512-7447 FAX
4061 Cobia Estates Dr
Cobia Cay Estates
Donald Epler dfepler@donaldepler.com
614-738-5279
360-933-5279 FAX
3321 Sunset Key
305 - Grande Isles II
Donald Epler dfepler@donaldepler.com
614-738-5279
360-933-5279 FAX
2060 Matecumbe Key Rd
2401 - Harbor Towers 2
Ray & Phyllis Love rlove2409@aol.com
941-505-2176
4051 Cobia Cay Estates Dr
Cobia Cay Estates
Tom & Mary Oaster Toasterjr@AOL.com
239-313-3358
239-262-5057 FAX
2090 Matecumbe Rd
Harbor Towers 1
John & Nancy Moretz diane.ruley@floridamoves.com
941-347-6371
800-448-3076
941-639-8419 FAX
3170 Matecumbe
234 - Keel Club
Bernie Punt & Wm. Jinkens joycebernie@comcast.net
941-505-0685
3181 Matecumbe Key
31 - The Resort
James & Jean Merz Jimmymerz@AOL.com
847-909-6470
17767 Courtside
                  Landings Circle 
Courtside Landings
Ron & Kay Hagen ronkayha@crosslake.net
218-692-4222
651-246-4111 cell
3410 Sunset Key Circle
D - Topaz Cove
Tom & Judy Green tomgreenpsu@aol.com
937-205-4870
937-748-2911 FAX
24081 Redfish Cove Dr
Redfish Cove
Helen Kendall cpmc-bsm@comcast.net
941-639-4886
941-639-4887 FAX
3020 Matecumbe Key Rd
203 - Marina Towers
Tom & Sandy Doty doty3203@verizon.net
260-432-6697
260-438-8823 cell 
17807 Hibiscus Cove Ct
Hibiscus Cove
Anthony & Gayle Barbarini marlin@neo.rr.com
330-544-1525
3181 Matecumbe Key Rd
23 - Resort
Joseph & Nancy Strykiewicz cpmc-bsm@comcast.net
941-639-4886
941-639-4887 FAX
4005 Big Pass Lane
Yellow Fin Cove
Brian O'Callaghan, Jr. brianager@comcast.net
941-505-1788
941-505-1788 FAX
2060 Matecumbe Key Road
2602 - Harbor Towers 2
Ed & Faith Gibson faith@FloridaGibson.com
239-707-5607
3 Pirates Lane
31B - Commodore's Club
Judy Coyne jdymc@btopenworld.com
2060 Matecumbe Key Rd
2307 - Harbor Towers 2
Diane Elliott ebb99@sbcglobal.net
231-383-0496
3160 Matecumbe Key Rd
224 - Keel Club 
Chuck Greenway 815-405-3175
read902@aol.com
105 Big Pine Lane Rocky & Ann Mansfield 941-639-4886
941-639-4887 FAX
cpmc-bsm@comcast.net
2060 Matecumbe Key Road
101 Harbor Towers 2
Albert & Rosemary Dowd 770-943-2833
770-443-8280 FAX
sanibelsunsets@aol.com
3321 Sunset Key Circle
501 Grande Isles 2
Albert & Rosemary Dowd 770-943-2833
770-443-8280 FAX
sanibelsunsets@aol.com
3181 Matecumbe Key Rd
35 - The Resort
Ernest & Barbara Criscuoli 941-639-4886
941-639-4887 FAX
cpmc-bsm@comcast.net
3321 Sunset Key Circle
306 - Grand Isles 2
Nicole Audibert 239-340-1362
239-558-8024 FAX
acolnie@yahoo.com
1001 Islamorada Blvd
12B - Rudder Club
Cal Corcoran 239-290-5227
calstl@yahoo.com
464 Sunset Key Circle
C - Emerald Isle
Paul Pochmara 586-291-3616
pockpa@sbcglobal.net
3235 Sugarloaf Key Rd.
11B - North Shore
Jane and John Seatter 941-575-8048
jseatter@embarqmail.com
3191Matecumbe Key Rd. 
406 - Vista Del Sol 
Ken & Janet Johnson
847-274-8107
847-432-3599 FAX
fsi1kj@aol.com
4 Pirates Lane
41C - Commodore's Club
John C. Spitler
888-866-2480
jspitler@neo.rr.com
3170 Matecumbe Key Rd.
223 - Keel Club
Paul & Deborah Nicholls
781-233-8264
pnicho68@comcast.net
3265 Sugarloaf Key Rd.
43A - North Shore
Sigi & Corinne Osicki
941-575-7441
sigio@aol.com 
1001 Islamorada Blvd.
11A - Rudder Club
Jackie & Don Audrian
314-302-5662
eglenst42@aol.com 
3321 Sunset Key Circle
2-405 - Grande Isles 2
Gordon & Bonnie Couperthwaite
239-731-0204
gordoncoup@comcast.net  
801 Islamorada Blvd.
21 B - Rudder Club
Liz Dunham & Blan Palmer
941-347-7779
diane.ruley@floridamoves.com

Note: The rental of these units is entirely at your own discretion and risk.  All dealings are directly between the owner, or owner’s representative and the renter.  BSGAC is not responsible or liable for any problems that may occur in the renting of these units.

Contact Webmaster about any website problems